ANALYSIS OF INDEPENDENT, CONTROLLED SURVEY

Return to Main Menu

ANALYSIS OF INDEPENDENT, CONTROLLED SURVEY

OF LIGHTNING STRIKE VICTIMS

BY JOHN R. CRENSHAW

TWO YEAR RESEARCH CONFIRMS

THAT THE USE OF COERCIVE PERSUASION (CP) AND HUMAN EXPERIMENTATION ON LIGHTNING STRIKE DEFENDANTS:

VIOLATED MIRANDA RULE

VIOLATED THEIR CIVIL RIGHTS

VIOLATED U.S. AND INTERNATIONAL LAWS -

VIOLATED HUMAN RIGHTS

CONSTITUTED MENTAL TORTURE

VIOLATED THE "NUREMBERG RULES" ON HUMAN EXPERIMENTATION

WAS UN-AMERICAN

THE SURVEY CONSISTED OF DETAILED QUESTIONNAIRES SUBMITTED BY 14 RESPONDENTS IN A CONTROLLED ENVIRONMENT BEFORE VICTIMS HAD CONTACT WITH ONE ANOTHER

11 PROSECUTED; 3 NOT PROSECUTED

ALL MALE CAUCASIANS; NO PRIOR CRIMINAL HISTORY

11 CONTRACTOR EMPLOYEES; 3 GOVERNMENT EMPLOYEES

10 OF 14 WERE EXPERIENCING SOME FAMILY CRISIS; AGENTS WERE AWARE OF CRISE

9 OF 11 PROSECUTED RESPONDENTS RECEIVED PRIOR LEGITIMATE PAYMENTS

12 OF 14 REPORTED AGENT PERSISTENTLY SUGGESTED BEHAVIOR - (ILLEGAL)

11 OF 14 DID NOT KNOW IT WAS ILLEGAL - PROCUREMENT LAW

13 OF 14 REPORTED AGENT USED "TRICKS" TO ENTRAP THEM

12 OF 14 WERE SUBJECTED TO A "COERCIVE INTERROGATION"

COERCIVE INTERROGATION IN LIGHTNING STRIKE

7 REPORTED GUNS FLASHED - SYMBOL OF AUTHORITY/FEAR

13 THREATENED WITH LONG IMPRISONMENT - THEN OFFERED LENIENCY "COOPERATE TO HELP YOURSELF"

12 WERE REQUIRED TO TAPE OTHER INNOCENT PEOPLE - NO PREDISPOSITION - RUMORS AND GOSSIP

NONE OF THE 14 WERE FORMALLY ARRESTED

NONE OF THE 14 WERE READ THE MIRANDA RIGHTS

10 TOLD NOT TO CONTACT A LAWYER

14 FLATTERED AND TOLD THEY WERE "BASICALLY GOOD PEOPLE"

13 TOLD THERE WAS SERIOUS CRIME/CORRUPTION AT JSC

13 OFFERED LENIENCY FOR COOPERATION

14 REPORTED NO EXISTING CRIME BEING FOUND

9 HELPED TO INCRIMINATE ONE OF THE "NASA-13"

12 WARNED NOT TO TALK TO PRESS - BLOW INVESTIGATION

4 WHO RESISTED - GOVERNMENT SOUGHT JAIL SENTENCES

10 REPORTED GOVERNMENT PRESS RELEASES EXAGGERATED THEIR CRIMINAL CHARGE

13 HAD REASON TO BELIEVE THEIR PHONES WERE TAPPED - EVEN AFTER COUNSEL APPOINTED/RETAINED!

14 BELIEVE THAT THEIRS AND OTHERS CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS VIOLATED

THIS WAS A "COORDINATED PROGRAM OF COERCIVE INFLUENCE"

(PER SINGER - 1990)

PAGE 1 OF 5

NAME names have been changed to reflect each persons case number	RACE	SEX	NASA OR CONTRACTOR	PRIOR INVESTIGATIONS / CONVICTIONS	WHO INTRODUCED YOU TO FRANCIS OR INTERMEDIARY	WERE YOU EXPERIENCING A PERSONAL CRISIS OR SEVERE PERSONAL PROBLEM WHEN YOU MET FRANCIS?	DID FRANCIS KNOW OF THIS PROBLEM?	DID FRANCIS MAKE ANY PRIOR LEGITIMATE PAYMENTS TO YOU?	HOW MANY?
1. H94-19	CAU	M	C	None	H94-18	Yes	Yes	Yes	7-8
2. H94-38	CAU	M	C	None	H94-18	Yes	Yes	Yes	6
3. H94-35	CAU	M	G-NASA	None	H94-38	Yes	Yes	NA	NA
4. H94-132	CAU	M	G-NASA	None	H94-36	Yes	Yes	No	NA
5. H94-36	CAU	M	C	None	H94-18	Yes	Yes	Yes	NA
6. H94-37	CAU	M	C	None	H94-18 H94-38	Yes	Yes	Yes	3
7. John Crenshaw	CAU	M	C	None	Thru H94-18	No	NA	No	NA
8. H94-34 (a)	CAU	M	C	None	H94-43 (b)	No	NA	No	NA
9. [Anonymity Requested by Participant]	CAU	M	C	None	D. Brown	No	NA	Yes	2
10. H94-14	CAU	M	C	None	H94-18 J. Crenshaw	No	NA	Yes	8-9
11. H94-18	CAU	M	C	None	J.H. Francis (FBI)	Yes	Yes	Yes	Many (8)
12. H95-42	CAU	M	C	None	H94-18	Yes	Yes	Yes	2 1/2
13. H94-01	CAU	M	G-DOD	None	H94-37	Yes	Yes	None	NA
14. Anthony Hodgson	CAU	M	C	None	D. Brown	Yes	Yes	Yes	2

SUMMARY: 14 14 3 Gov.11 C0N 14 10 10 9

IG / DOJ / FBI - MR. FRANCIS "MODUS OPERANDI"

PAGE 2 OF 5

DID FRANCIS SUGGEST THE ILLEGAL ACTIVITY?	DID YOU KNOW IT WAS ILLEGAL?	HOW MANY TIMES DID HE TRY TO GET YOU TO DO IT?	DO YOU BELIEVE HE "TRICKED" YOU INTO BREAKING THE LAW?	DO YOU BELIEVE THAT YOU WERE ENTRAPPED?	DID YOU GET THE WAREHOUSE "TREATMENT"?	WERE GUNS PROMINENTLY FLASHED?	WERE YOU OFFERED THE OPPORTUNITY TO "HELP YOURSELF" BY COOPERATING?	DID YOU SUBSEQUENTLY LEARN THIS INVOLVED WIRETAPPING OF OTHERS?
1. Yes	No	Many	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes
2. Yes	Yes	Many	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	Yes	Yes
3. Yes	No	4-6	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	Yes	Yes
4. No	No	NA	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes
5. Yes	No	Many	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes
6. Yes	No	10-11	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes
7. Yes	Unethical	NA (1)	Yes (He Tried)	Yes (He Tried)	No	NA	NA	NA
8. Yes	No	1	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes
9. Yes	No	10+	He Tried	Yes	Yes	No	Yes	Yes
10. Yes	Yes	2-3	Yes	Yes	At Wash. Off. Yes	No	Yes	Yes
11. Yes	UNK	Many	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes
12. Yes	No	5	Yes	Yes	No	NA	Yes	NA
13. Yes	No	3	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes
14. No	No	Many	NA	Yes	Yes	No	Yes	Yes

12 Yes 10 No 13 14 12 7 13 12

IG / DOJ / FBI / MR. FRANCIS "MODUS OPERANDI"

PAGE 3 OF 5

WERE YOU ARRESTED?	WERE YOU READ YOUR MIRANDA RIGHTS?	WERE YOU OFFERED THE RIGHT TO CONTACT A LAWYER?	WERE YOU TOLD NOT TO CONTACT A LAWYER?	WERE YOU TOLD THAT THIS WOULD BLOW THE WHOLE INVESTIGATION?	WERE YOU TOLD THAT YOU WERE A BASICALLY GOOD PERSON?	WERE YOU TOLD THAT THERE WERE SERIOUS CRIMES AT JSC?	WERE YOU TOLD OR WAS IT IMPLIED THAT YOUR HELP WOULD LEAD TO LENIENCY?
1. No	No	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes
2. No	No	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes
3. No	No	No	No	No	Yes	Yes	Yes
4. No	No	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes
5. No	No	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes
6. No	No	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes
7. No	No	NA	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes
8. No	No	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes
9. No	No	No	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes
10. No	No	No	No	No	Yes	No	Yes
11. No	No	Yes-But	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes
12. No	No	No	-	No	Yes	Yes	Yes
13. No	No	No	No	No	Yes	Yes	Yes
14. No	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes

14 14 11 No 10 9 14 13 13

IG / DOJ / FBI / MR. FRANCIS "MODUS OPERANDI"

PAGE 4 OF 5

WERE YOU TOLD OR WAS IT IMPLIED THAT CHARGES MIGHT BE REDUCED OR DROPPED?	DID YOU DISCOVER ANY ACTUAL CRIMES BEING COMMITTED?	DID YOU HELP TO INCRIMINATE ANOTHER PERSON IN A CRIME?	WHO?	WAS THIS CRIME SUGGESTED TO THE VICTIM?	DO YOU BELIEVE YOURS / OTHERS CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS WERE VIOLATED?
1. Yes	Yes	Yes	L. Stevenson Astro People	UNK	Yes
2. Yes	No	Yes	S. Cleland	No	Yes
3. Yes	No	No	NA	NA	Yes
4. Yes	Yes	Yes	C. Huntoon et al	No	Yes
5. Yes	Yes	Yes	D. Proctor	Yes	Yes
6. Yes	No	Yes	C. Alexander	Yes	Yes
7. NA	No	No	-	NA	Yes
8. Yes	No	Yes	D. Shaffer	UNK	Yes
9. Yes	Yes	Yes	P.L. Feng	Yes	Yes
10. Yes	No	No	NA	NA	Yes
11. Yes	No	Yes	D. Brown	Yes	Yes
12. Yes	No	No	NA	NA	Yes
13. Yes	No	Yes	Walbrecher, Rummel, Huntoon	Yes	Yes
14. NA	Yes	No	NA	NA	Yes

12 9 No 9 Yes 5 14

IG/DOJ / FBI / MR. FRANCIS "MODUS OPERANDI"

PAGE 5 OF 5

WERE YOU WARNED NOT TO TALK TO THE PRESS?	DID GOV�T PRESS RELEASES EXAGGERATE THE CRIME YOU WERE CHARGED WITH?	DO YOU HAVE REASON TO BELIEVE YOUR PHONE IS OR HAS BEEN TAPPED?
1. Yes	Yes	Yes
2. Yes	Yes	Yes
3. Yes	Yes	UNK
4. Yes	Yes	Yes
5. Yes	Yes	Yes
6. Yes	Yes	Yes
7. Yes	NA	Yes
8. Yes	Yes	Yes
9. No	NA	Yes
10. No	No	Yes
11. Yes	Yes	Yes
12. Yes	Yes	Yes
13. Yes	Yes	Yes
14. Yes	NA	Yes

12 10 13

Return to Title Page